OVER THE WALL

What’s Your Number?

Immigration. A few weeks ago, I wrote that the issue remained a hot-button with the MAGA movement, with the president and especially his newly appointed chief of staff, Stephen Miller. Just this past week, the president threatened Mexico with a doubling of tariffs if they didn’t stop an immigrant caravan crossing the southern Mexican border trying to get to the United States.

In the wake of the Nov. 3 mid-term elections, the president first opined that maybe the immigration crackdown executed by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents may have gone too far. His rare mea culpa immediately got pushback from MAGA diehards, calling his comments a betrayal of their principles. With the elevation of Miller to chief of staff, one can logically assume the mea culpa has already been long forgotten and Miller’s push for even tougher immigration enforcement is now back.

It is time to reframe the immigration argument.

Most of us are descendants of immigrants to the New World, or the nation-state called the United States of America, founded in 1776. If you can trace your family to 549 registered North American tribes like the Mohawks, Cherokees, Navajos, Sioux, among the better-known ones, you can claim Pre-American lineage. But it is estimated that less than 1 percent of Americans today have Native American ancestry. There is another subset of non-indigenous peoples that pre-date the American Revolution: Spaniards in New Spain and the French in the Lousiana Purchase. Even they were immigrants to the New World. Our immigrant ancestries mean that nearly every one of us has a history that started somewhere else, whether your beginnings are in Europe, Africa, Asia or Latin America.

On my father’s side, his great-grandfather arrived in New York from Germany in 1834. On my mother’s side, all Swedish immigrants, the earliest date is 1866. Both my father’s and mother’s immediate families settled in Nebraska and started farming.

On my wife’s mother’s side, her date is 1621, and they eventually settled in New Hampshire and Vermont in the early 1700s. On her father’s side, the arrival date of his ancestors in the New World is 1634.

For this column, I’m suggesting you have a “number” that is the earliest proven date an ancestor arrived in North America. My “number” is 1834. My wife’s “number” is 1621.

As an example, President Trump is a first-generation American. His father, Friedrich Trump immigrated from Germany in 1886, and his mother, Mary Anne MacLeod, arrived in 1930. His number would be 1886.

Many people might argue that assigning someone an “arrival” date could divide us, creating labels that might imply more legitimacy to call yourself American because you can trace your history back farther than someone else. I would argue exactly the opposite: your numbers give you a common denominator with everyone around you — your ancestors and theirs came from somewhere else. Even if you were born in America, as the vast majority of us are today (nearly 85 percent according to World Population Review), we wouldn’t be here if not for our immigrant ancestors.

This brings me back to today’s immigration debate. In 2015, the Gang of Eight (four Republican senators, including Marco Rubio, John McCain, Lindsey Graham and Jeff Flake, and four Democrats including Dick Durbin, Bob Menendez, Michael Bennett and Chuck Schumer) crafted a comprehensive immigration reform bill. The Senate-approved version stalled in the House of Representatives because Speaker John Boehner refused to bring it to the floor for a vote. Some political observers have suggested candidate Donald Trump didn’t want the bill passed because even then he wanted to make immigration one of his pet attack points to divide the Democratic Party.

In a nutshell, and condensed for a quick read, the bill offered a path to citizenship (proven five-year residency, no criminal convictions, language proficiency, among other items) for illegal aliens, improved work visa processing with priority given to foreigners with advanced degrees, an expanded and improved employee verification program to return responsibility for proving citizenship to employers and improved work options for low-skill workers, especially agricultural workers. It also allocated $48 billion for improved border security (nearly $70 billion in 2026 dollars and new Customs and Border Protection (CBP) hires.

Sounds reasonable, doesn’t it? Instead of that law, we have had years of ad hoc enforcement and political posturing, building walls and finally putting armed patrols on the streets, violating Constitutional rights to arrest people who happened to look like they might be illegal aliens. That is crazy. The evidence is all around us today that without comprehensive immigration reform, chaos has reigned. It is tragic that a bipartisan solution was on the table and was derailed. At the very least, the law should have been put to the test.

Let’s frame immigration this way: we are all immigrants, we all have our “number” and we should all be treated equally by the law. With a rational, legal and humane immigration policy, we can get back to one of the foundational principles of the modern United States of America engraved on the Statue of Liberty: “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.”

What’s your number?

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply